In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
Assalaamu `alaykum waRahmatullahi Wabarakatuhu
To Understand the Actual Issue between Ashari-Maturidi Vs Slafis Following is the chronology of events and Issues.These heading has been arranged in a way to convey the message in Brief. The detail of Points will be put in the link........... Help the Ummat e Muhammad Compaign.............
Although in Fiqh there was difference of opinion and four School of thought but in Aqeedah it was only one.
There was no difference
in Aqeedah till 200-300 Hijri.(850-950 A.C) There was no Ashari-Maturidi or
Salafi School of thought.
MODULE 1
HOW THE EVENTS STARTED?
These Deviated Sect were led by Muatazellah.
Influence of Muatazellah
on the Muslim Rulers.There rise at the time of Mamun and Muatasim kingship
Majority of Ulema Under Pressure
from King became silent against Deviated Sects in KHALQE QURAN ISSUE
MODULE 2 Arrival Of Imam Ahmad Ibne Hanbal Rahimullah
Arrival of Imam Ahmad
Ibne Hanbal for final debate. General Muslims were with Imam Ahmad.They raised his moral to face hardship for the cause of Islam.(Many incidents Imam Ahmad himself has narrated and written in his books please read and cry with joy.....I am also crying while writing these lines)
Imam Ahmad Ibne Hanbal
Solely fighting the Whole Band of Corrupted Scholar backed by Muslim Rulers.
Imam Ahmad Ibne Hanbal
victory in his en-devour.And dies. The King finally became his Follower
MODULE 3 After Imam Ahmad
Again Muatazillah came
after becoming logically stronger in their Corrupted Ideology
They gained Momentum
even more than earlier.
Imam Abul Hasan Ashari
was himself Muatazellah Initially.He was step son of a big muatazellah leader.
MODULE 4 Arrival of Imam Abul hasan Ashari in Ahle Sunnat Side
Allah turned the heart
of Imam Ashari to Ahle Sunnat AFTER 15 YEARS BEING Mutazellah
He announced his
departure from Muatazellah in Mosque before Friday Prayer.
He started direct
Ideological onslaught on Muatazellah.
MODULE 5 Abul Hasan Ashari Used two way
Approach.
First Part of his
Approach
Second Part of his
Approach
He established the
Supermacy of Ahle Sunnat Stand over Muatazillah
Imam Abu Mansur Maturidi
After Abul Hasan Ashari
Imam Maturidi did some Refinement of the work. Very minimal difference. Both
accept each other.It is more a new edition rather than a new work.
MODULE 6 The only significant
difference between Ashari-Maturidi Vs Slafi Aqeedah is in description of Attributes of Allah (Correct explanation of some of the Ayats and Hadith)
Sahaba Position on Attributes of Alah
Slafus Slaehin Scholars Position on Attributes of Allah and their Advise to muslim scholars/general Muslims on this issue
Imam Malik Position and Advice
Imam Tahawi Advice
Imam Shafaee Advice
MODULE 7 Salafi accusation on Ashari Maturidi is of Taweel. (
MODULE 9 Ashari Maturidi accusation on Salafi is of Tajseem
(attributing creation like characteristics to Allah in description like hand Eyes) .Slaf Position for these Ayats has already come earlier.
Some Criticism are there that Ibne Taimmiya Rahimullah has exceeded the limits and has entered into Tajseem. But Ibne Taimmiya himself has strongly denied it.
Majority of Salafi Scholars are not doing Tajseem.
A small minority has exceeded the limit and has written ambiguous sentences that indicate Tajseem.
Main Reason is their over Refutation of Taweel with examples led to this fault
Sahaba Position on Attributes of Alah
Slafus Slaehin Scholars Position on Attributes of Allah and their Advise to muslim scholars/general Muslims on this issue
Imam Malik Position and Advice
Imam Tahawi Advice
Imam Shafaee Advice
MODULE 7 Salafi accusation on Ashari Maturidi is of Taweel. (
What is Taweel?
Taweel was done by Imam Abul Hasan not out of fun rather out of necessity.
Imam has himself Clarified his Position in his book.
Present Day Ashari-Maturidi Scholar are not doing Taweel
Present Day Ashari-Maturidi Scholar are not doing Taweel
MODULE 8 Who are Present day Ashari Maturidi Position on Taweel.
What is position of Present day scholars of Ashari Maturidi on Taweel.
Present day scholars are not doing Taweel. They have declared in many Fatwa.
They ARE only telling that when it was done by Abul Hasan Ashari it was right as the situation was like this in 300 hijri.It was done to quell the Ideological Fitnah of Muatazellah.
There Fatawa about not doing Taweel.
Evidence 1 that present day Scholars are not doing Taweel
Evidence 2 that present day Scholars are not doing Taweel
MODULE 9 Ashari Maturidi accusation on Salafi is of Tajseem
(attributing creation like characteristics to Allah in description like hand Eyes) .Slaf Position for these Ayats has already come earlier.
Some Criticism are there that Ibne Taimmiya Rahimullah has exceeded the limits and has entered into Tajseem. But Ibne Taimmiya himself has strongly denied it.
Majority of Salafi Scholars are not doing Tajseem.
A small minority has exceeded the limit and has written ambiguous sentences that indicate Tajseem.
Main Reason is their over Refutation of Taweel with examples led to this fault
MODULE 10 Actually Ashari- Maturidi Vs Slafi dispute is Nothing to do with Aqeedah
Islamic Aqeedah is very clear
Classical text like Aqeedatut Tahawi is sufficient for a Muslim to be perfect in Aqeedah.
MODEL Slafus Salehin Position was not to go into this philosphical detail
No need for a Muslim to go into these Philosphical Logical debate.
These are nothing to do with basic tents of Islamic Faith.
These are not more than a Fitnah
MODULE 12 When Ashari not doing Taweel and Salafi not doing Tajseem Why there is verbal fighting.
Mainstream actual Greats of Ashari and Salfi are not doing Taweel or Tajseem Respectively
MODULE 13 First Tier Great Scholars are not Fighting.
They have Harmonious relation (Ex.Sheikh Ibne Baaz (Salafi) & Sheikh Abul Hasan Nadvi (Ashari-Maturidi,Hanafi,Soofi) used to Co chair Rabta Islami meeting
Second tier Scholars are learned people busy with Other Islamic work. Working on Positive front OF Dawah Taleem etc.Have very little interaction with scholars of other school. Minimal or no relation with internet/ direct contact with public.
MODULE 14 Verbal Fighting is in between 3rd Tier Scholar/ Non Scholars with strong group Affliation
MODULE 15 They are mostly busy in attacking other for secterian gain /Groupism under cover of Aqeedah.
Islamic Aqeedah is very clear
Classical text like Aqeedatut Tahawi is sufficient for a Muslim to be perfect in Aqeedah.
MODEL Slafus Salehin Position was not to go into this philosphical detail
No need for a Muslim to go into these Philosphical Logical debate.
These are nothing to do with basic tents of Islamic Faith.
These are not more than a Fitnah
MODULE 12 When Ashari not doing Taweel and Salafi not doing Tajseem Why there is verbal fighting.
Mainstream actual Greats of Ashari and Salfi are not doing Taweel or Tajseem Respectively
MODULE 13 First Tier Great Scholars are not Fighting.
They have Harmonious relation (Ex.Sheikh Ibne Baaz (Salafi) & Sheikh Abul Hasan Nadvi (Ashari-Maturidi,Hanafi,Soofi) used to Co chair Rabta Islami meeting
Second tier Scholars are learned people busy with Other Islamic work. Working on Positive front OF Dawah Taleem etc.Have very little interaction with scholars of other school. Minimal or no relation with internet/ direct contact with public.
MODULE 14 Verbal Fighting is in between 3rd Tier Scholar/ Non Scholars with strong group Affliation
Third tier Scholars are on
internet/ Publishing books/Making you tube videos.
They are directly connected to People of their respective groups.
Majority of
them even don’t know good Arabic to understand classical Text.
They have not
gone deep to the classical text and historical Background to understand the
whole issue.
Their deficiency in Taqwa is another big issue.
Some of them are
working as paid employee of some individual Muslim/organization for the sole
purpose of maligning other Scholars and group.
Some are for easy Popularity.
Most of them have no contribution to the any field of Islam except these
issues.
MODULE 15 They are mostly busy in attacking other for secterian gain /Groupism under cover of Aqeedah.
(Don’t be amzed History repeats itself. It has happened in past in Umma. Read the history of salfussalehin like Imam Abu Haneefa, Imam Ahmad, Imam Ibne Taimmiya.
Read the history why Abu Hayyan (An scholar of Nahu at his time ) became the foremost opposer of Ibne Taimiyya Rahimullah….....ohhhhhhhhhh).
MODULE 16 Some Islamic TV Channels/ English Urdu speaking scholars has indirectly contributed to make it complex.
They are mostly good people.
Shaitan has filled a sense in them that they are only servicing Islam
Dont blame them They are good people Shaitan has played special trick with them
They criticise other groups for some reson/Donot go with opinion of a particular Fiqh prevalent in the country. it cause mistrust and widen the divide.
Suppose Some one is criticizing Hanafi Fiqh and most of the Hanafi are Ashari-Maturidi so it does not take time that other make it an Aqeedah issues.
Classical example is .................................
Module 17
There is a lot of Aam Admi (General
Public) Non Scholar with different level of Understanding , Temperament who has
seen videos of these third tier leaders.
They have read only the writing of
these third layer scholars/slamic TV Channels/ Urdu English speaking scholars
They don’t understand the issues.
Rather they
understand that other group is Mushrik/Baatil Aqeedah/Deviated/Twisting Hadith
according to wish/Just short of Kafir/Some even declare Kafir.
MODULE 18 Aqeedah is a emotional and Basic Isuue that why they correlate all differences to make Aqeedah Isuues.
..........Help the ummat e muhammad compaighn..........
..........Understand and Stand for Ummat.........
Come and Join Share it ............
Make Help group at local level.........
To be continued..........Insha Allah
..........Understand and Stand for Ummat.........
Come and Join Share it ............
Make Help group at local level.........
To be continued..........Insha Allah
Jazakallah khair for this blog!
ReplyDelete